Healthy Debate
  • Search
  • Health topics
  • Debates
  • Special Series
  • All topics
  • All articles
Most popular today
  • COVID-19 (567)
  • Vaccines (140)
  • Opioids (52)
  • Cancer (162)
  • Addiction (172)
  • Racism (39)
  • Alcohol (23)
  • Infectious Disease (684)
  • Marijuana (22)
  • Tobacco (21)
  • Aging (212)
  • Dementia (45)
  • Long-Term Care (84)
  • Children and Youth (277)
  • Education (384)
  • Medical Education (192)
  • Depression (26)
  • Misinformation (110)
  • Nursing (29)
  • End of Life (182)
  • In Memoriam (5)
  • MAiD (33)
  • Environment (69)
  • Climate Change (35)
  • About
  • Subscribe
Opinion
Feb 6, 2012
by Ashley Miller

Is stuff making us sick? part 2

0 Comments
Share on:

In my last post I explored how stress, debt, and environmental destruction seem like obvious implications of consumption.  But what if too-much-stuff is also the source of physical illness?  John de Graaf, David Wann, and Thomas Naylor brilliantly address this issue in their book Affluenza: The All Consuming Epidemic in their depiction of consumerism as a disease itself! Their compelling portrayal of material consumption is as a contagious “virus” that infects individuals, creating harmful symptoms while distracting us from the very activities that make us thriving humans, such as rewarding work and meaningful relationships.

While this work is thought provoking and glaringly true based on my personal experience (as a consumer), I was interested to find that “affluenza” has now been described in scientific literature as well. I found reference to the phenomenon in multiple journals including Critical Public Health[i], Journal of Affective Disorders[iii], Global Health Promotion[iv], Journal of Mental Health[v], and even in the Journal of the American College of Cardiology.[vi]

Some of this is in direct reference to one aspect of affluenza, which is the excessive consumption of processed food and its contribution to obesity related illness. But there is less predictably a fair amount of literature related to the impact of consumerism on child and adolescent mental health. The consensus seems to be that the increasing relationship between self-validation and material possession is significantly contributing to anxiety and depression, while creating youth with low self-esteem and poor coping skills.

I would generalize that the impact of affluenza on a societal level has been an increasing shift away from an emphasis on acquisition of our fundamental needs towards an insatiable taste for goods that are harmful both in the toxic resources that go into their production and in their impact on our holistic wellness. While it is evident that the evolution of our capacity to attain necessities such as food and shelter has undoubtedly fostered health and greatly increased our life expectancy, it seems that we are now moving backwards once more as we become overworked, overloaded with debt, emotionally drained, and (literally) weighed down by our quest to attain more and more stuff. Stuff, it seems, is making us sick.

In Simple Prosperity, David Wann’s followup to Affluenza, he skillfully demonstrates how affluenza can be overcome through investment in “real wealth sources” such as strong social ties, goals of personal growth, cultural prosperity, and respect for nature. I have to agree with him that curing the disease of over-consumption will lead to richer, and surely healthier, lives.

For a fun, terrifying, and hopeful account of how we got here and where we’re going, please watch Annie Leonard’s inspired “The Story of Stuff.”

[i] Bendelow, G. (2010). Emotional health: Challenging biomedicine or increasing health surveillance? Critical Public Health, 20(4), 465-474.,;Crawshaw, P. (2008). Whither wellbeing for public health? Critical Public Health, 18(3), 259-261.; Petersen, A., Davis, M., Fraser, S., & Lindsay, J. (2010). Healthy living and citizenship: An overview. Critical Public Health, 20(4), 391-400.

[ii] Cooper, C., Bebbington, P., & Livingston, G. (2011). Cognitive impairment and happiness in old people in low and middle income countries: Results from the 10/66 study. Journal of Affective Disorders, 130(1-2), 198-204.

[iii] Hanlon, P., & Carlisle, S. (2009). Is ‘modern culture’ bad for our health and well-being? Global Health Promotion, 16(4), 27-34.

[iv] Spandler, H., & Stickley, T. (2011). No hope without compassion: The importance of compassion in recovery-focused mental health services. Journal of Mental Health, 20(6), 555-566.

[v] Cheng, T. O. (2003). Fast food and obesity in china. Journal of the American College of Cardiology, 42(4), 773-773.

[vi] Garland, EJ. (2008). The sad adolescent: A practical approach for recognizing and helping the teen struggling with depression.  Speech presented at the Canadian Paediatric Society Annual Conference, Victoria, British Columbia.

Share on:
Author

Ashley Miller

Contributor

Republish this article

Republish this article on your website under the creative commons licence.

Learn more

The comments section is closed.

Author

Ashley Miller

Contributor

Republish this article

Republish this article on your website under the creative commons licence.

Learn more

Donate to Healthy Debate

Your support allows us to publish journalism about healthcare in Canada that is free to read and free to republish. Donations are tax-deductible.

Donate

Join the mailing list

Sign up below to receive our newsletter every Thursday morning.

You can republish our articles online or in print for free. Read more.

Republish us
  • About
  • Contribute
  • Contact
  • Community Guidelines
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

Republish this article

  1. Please use the invisible republishing code below on the page where you republish this article.
  2. Please give credit to Healthy Debate and include a link back to our home page or the article URL . Our preference is a credit at the top of the article and that you include our logo  (available by clicking the link below).

Please read the full set of instructions for republication here.