Healthy Debate
  • Search
  • Health topics
  • Debates
  • Special Series
  • All topics
  • All articles
Most popular today
  • COVID-19 (567)
  • Vaccines (140)
  • Opioids (53)
  • Cancer (163)
  • Addiction (175)
  • Racism (39)
  • Alcohol (23)
  • Infectious Disease (685)
  • Marijuana (23)
  • Tobacco (22)
  • Aging (213)
  • Dementia (46)
  • Long-Term Care (84)
  • Children and Youth (277)
  • Education (386)
  • Medical Education (193)
  • Depression (26)
  • Misinformation (110)
  • Nursing (29)
  • End of Life (183)
  • In Memoriam (5)
  • MAiD (33)
  • Environment (70)
  • Climate Change (35)
  • About
  • Subscribe
Opinion
Oct 19, 2015
by Laura Muldoon Sarah Ritchie

Mental illness shouldn’t mean a shortened life

0 Comments
Share on:

Serious mental illnesses, such as schizophrenia and bipolar disorder, have a profound impact on the lives of the people affected by them. About 1% of the Canadian population has schizophrenia and 1% suffers from bipolar disorder, according to the Canadian Mental Health Association. People with major mental illnesses also have higher rates of other acute and chronic diseases. It’s estimated people with major mental health illnesses die 25 years earlier, on average, compared to the general population. Much of this excess sickness and death is due to preventable conditions, especially cardiovascular disease, according to an analysis by the U.S. National Association of State Mental Health Program Directors.

Multiple factors—such as obesity, smoking, poor diet, substance misuse, physical inactivity, and some antipsychotic medications—are implicated in increasing the risk of cardiovascular problems in these populations. Despite their higher burden of illness, persons with serious mental disorders are less likely to be diagnosed or treated for the physical conditions they have, such as hypertension, dyslipidemia and diabetes.

What is the cause of this terrible health inequity? There are likely several factors at play, occurring at the levels of society, the health care system, the healthcare providers and the patients. At a societal level, people tend to  marginalize and discriminate against people with serious mental illnesses. Research has shown that this stigma can lead to patients avoiding care.

The health care system also worsens health inequity, with health care divided into care for diseases of the body and care for diseases of the mind. Mental health professionals are rarely located in the same facility as primary care providers who could address the screening and treatment people with serious mental illnesses need for conditions like hypertension or diabetes. Effective communication between the providers of mental and physical health care is rare in Canada’s health care system. Evidence-based models of collaborative mental health care between primary care providers and psychiatrists are known to improve patient outcomes but are not widespread.

Beyond the issues with how our health system is set up, personal factors relating to both primary care providers and the patients themselves can pose barriers to care. Primary care providers may perceive caring for people who are considered medically complicated as a burden, and be overwhelmed by the competing demands of helping people with multiple issues. For patients, their mental illnesses can limit their motivation to seek or follow through on care or cause them to be fearful and mistrusting of the system and the providers in it. Patients with serious mental illnesses also tend to experience homelessness or unstable housing, poverty, and social isolation – all of which can interfere with their ability to find and stick to a family health provider.

While we cannot address all of the health system, societal or personal barriers that people with serious mental illnesses face, we can immediately begin to adjust our own behaviours and attitudes to be more inclusive towards people with serious mental illnesses. We encourage health providers to adopt what we call the “four Rs”. The first is recognition. At our community health centre, our staff do not  focus simply on the presenting problem (a foot infection, for example), but rather look for the underlying issues as well (for example, poor housing or  lack of access to transportation and healthy food ) and try to help the person deal with these issues. The second R is respect. It is vital to see patients as people, with talents, hopes, and fears, rather than seeing simply the mental illness. The third R is resources. We in primary care can’t do everything for everybody all the time. We need to know what supports for our patients with mental illness exist in our own community. We have realized that connections to housing, food, and meaningful interactions in the community are more important than medical supports for many people. The fourth R is relationships. We must work to build trusting relationships with patients and sustain them over time. This is probably the most powerful tool we have in our toolbox.

Share on:
Authors

Laura Muldoon

Contributor

Laura Muldoon is a primary care physician at the Somerset West Community Health Centre in Ottawa.

Sarah Ritchie

Contributor

Sarah Ritchie is a third year medical student at the University of Ottawa wishing to pursue a career in Family Medicine.

Republish this article

Republish this article on your website under the creative commons licence.

Learn more

The comments section is closed.

Authors

Laura Muldoon

Contributor

Laura Muldoon is a primary care physician at the Somerset West Community Health Centre in Ottawa.

Sarah Ritchie

Contributor

Sarah Ritchie is a third year medical student at the University of Ottawa wishing to pursue a career in Family Medicine.

Republish this article

Republish this article on your website under the creative commons licence.

Learn more

Donate to Healthy Debate

Your support allows us to publish journalism about healthcare in Canada that is free to read and free to republish. Donations are tax-deductible.

Donate

Join the mailing list

Sign up below to receive our newsletter every Thursday morning.

You can republish our articles online or in print for free. Read more.

Republish us
  • About
  • Contribute
  • Contact
  • Community Guidelines
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

Republish this article

  1. Please use the invisible republishing code below on the page where you republish this article.
  2. Please give credit to Healthy Debate and include a link back to our home page or the article URL . Our preference is a credit at the top of the article and that you include our logo  (available by clicking the link below).

Please read the full set of instructions for republication here.