Article

New Year’s resolutions from health-care professionals: Advocate, avoid burnout and remember to love

I’ll come out and say it: On the surface, the evidence behind New Year’s resolutions doesn’t look great.

One study found that from week one to two into the new year, the number of resolutioners who kept their goal plummeted from 77 to a meagre 19 per cent. Worse yet, other studies have shown that more than 90 per cent of resolutioners will give up completely after just a few months.

With outcomes this bleak, it’s tempting to wonder if there’s any use in making resolutions at all.

But some of the latest research  suggests that judging the success of resolutions may not be so black and white.

Despite periodic lapses, between 20 and 40 per cent of participants in two recent studies did achieve their goal by the end of the year. A further 30 to 60 per cent also hadn’t given up, and at year’s end reported that they were “still working at it.”

In fact, only one to three per cent said they had “deliberately disengaged” from pursuing their goal entirely. Studies like these suggest that determining whether our goals have been achieved might be, at least in part, a matter of perspective.

Keeping New Year’s resolutions doesn’t have to be a statistical improbability that leaves gyms empty by the end of January and new hobbies left untouched by mid-year.

Resolutioners were found to be significantly more effective in achieving their goals when they had support from others. Another study found that approach-oriented goals were much more likely to be successful than avoidance-oriented goals (think “I will sign up for art classes” instead of “I will stop eating sugar”).

But even those who have opted for avoidance-oriented goals should take comfort in knowing that setbacks are normal. Those who kept up with an avoidance-oriented goal for up to two years, reported having “slipped” as many as 14 times. But that doesn’t mean that all those gains made were lost. The mere practice of setting a goal – particularly an affirmative one – seems to set us up for improvements one way or another.

One study found that those who make New Year’s resolutions are more likely to report achieving their goals and solving problems six months into the year than non-resolvers (46 per cent compared with just four per cent).

Whether our goals are individual or collective, arguably there is still some utility in setting intentions for the future – and thinking creatively about how we can measure our successes.

At a time when the problems in Canadian health care can feel overwhelming and reaching our goals seems a daunting task, we wanted to know what health-care experts have on their personal resolutions list for 2025.

Joe Vipond,

emergency physician, co-founder of the Canadian COVID Society, and past president of the Canadian Association of Physicians for the Environment

During a time of poly crisis, I tend to overwork on trying to improve things. I need to be more conscious of taking time for myself because if I burn out, then obviously, all the work that I do stops. I need to focus on being kind to myself and to be kind to what I believe is the important work I do on both COVID and climate.

It can be a never-ending bucket to fill. The bucket just keeps getting bigger and bigger as the problems grow. But you fail everyone if you fail yourself.

Sabina Vohra-Miller,

founder Unambiguous Science and Doctor of Public Health candidate at Dalla Lana School of Public Health

I don’t really do New Year’s resolutions, mostly because I’m an impatient Type A person, so if there is something I want to change about my life, I am the type to do it the very next day!

That said, I do want to continue with evidence-based living such as ensuring I am eating wholesome meals, getting at minimum seven hours of sleep daily, lifting weights and doing cardio at least four or five times per week, drinking less than two alcoholic beverages per week, spending as much time as possible outdoors and laughing and making new core memories as often as I can! Oh, and holding our government accountable every single day.

Alan Drummond,

family and emergency physician

I started in medical school at McGill in 1974. From almost the very first day, we were taught to uphold the dignity of the person and to respect the patient’s right to privacy and strict confidentiality. That was then and this is now. As an emergency physician in 21st century Ontario, I practice largely in an emergency department hallway, and oftentimes, when they are filled, in a chair in full public view, or as we call it in Ontario, “an unconventional space.”

Sadly, I now discuss intimate personal details within earshot of other waiting patients or discuss a new diagnosis of a terminal cancer in a hallway. It’s either that or the patients will wait an unbearable length of time, and many will give up in frustration and leave without assessment or a diagnosis.

News travels fast in a small town and I am now officially tired of denigrating my Hippocratic oath on a daily basis. So, my New Year’s resolution is to commit to reminding political leaders, regulatory authorities and hospital administrations that we must collectively do better in getting back to the basics, respecting confidentiality and restoring dignity in our patient interactions.

Raywat Deonandan,

professor and epidemiologist, Faculty of Health Sciences at the University of Ottawa

I don’t believe in resolutions. But I do believe in personal philosophies. And my ongoing resolution, not just for the New Year, is to live philosophically: To devote time and resources only to things that are truly important and to remember to love everyone – even my enemies. It sounds pretentious and hollow to some. But as I age, I become increasingly confident that a surfeit of anonymous generalized love is what is sorely lacking in the world.

Timothy Caulfield,

author and professor of Healthy Law and Science Policy at the University of Alberta

My New Year’s resolution is to step away from the noise more often! Research consistently shows that taking a break from our chaotic – and way too negative and rage-filled – information environment is good for both our mental health and critical thinking. I need to take my own advice! Chill.

Doris Grinspun,

O.Ont. CEO, Registered Nurses’ Association of Ontario

In recent years, Canada has made meaningful strides in addressing the social and environmental determinants of health – such as child benefits, childcare, dental care, the beginnings of universal pharmacare and action on the climate emergency. We also have advanced equity, diversity and inclusion while striving to uphold the rights of all Canadians. Yet, much work remains.

My resolution for the New Year is to inspire and influence as many people as possible to continue this progress and resist any movement backward.

The alarming trends in the U.S. serve as a stark warning: efforts to dismantle social benefits and environmental protections to further enrich billionaires, alongside escalating attacks on trans, Black, immigrant and Indigenous communities. Signs of this regression are already evident in Canada – look no further than developments in Alberta.

It would be a tragedy to see divisiveness gain ground in Canada. Instead, we must remain committed to a more inclusive and sustainable future for this remarkable country we call home.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Authors

Maddi Dellplain

Digital Editor and Staff Writer

Maddi Dellplain is a national award-nominated journalist specializing in health reporting. Maddi works across multiple mediums with an emphasis on long-form features and audio-based storytelling. Her work has appeared in The Tyee, Megaphone Magazine, J-Source and more.

maddi@healthydebate.ca
Republish this article

Republish this article on your website under the creative commons licence.

Learn more