Opinions

This category is used to mark all Opinions pieces in the Informed Opinions Section of Healthydebate.ca

Did a conflict over intellectual property delay the Ebola vaccine?

Matthew Herder

Friday, October 3, 2014: A CBC headline read, “Could Ebola vaccine delay be due to an intellectual property spat?” By the next morning a colleague, Richard Gold of McGill, and I had figured out that the “IP” (intellectual property) was in fact a non-story. Whatever was delaying the start of a research trial to test

Direct to consumer genetic testing in Canada: should we be concerned?

Timothy Caulfield healthy debate blogger

The highest profile direct-to-consumer genetic testing company in the world, 23andMe, has opened shop in Canada.  In addition to providing information about your genetic ancestry (turns out I am 100% Irish), 23andMe will, after your genetic information is pulled from the required tube of spit, provide you with a whole bunch of genetic risk information

Building trust between physicians and patients in an era of Dr. Google

Yan Xu healthy debate blogger

Clinical knowledge has now become easier to obtain than ever. Open-access medical journals that waive subscription fees for readers, electronic medical record systems such as My e-Health in British Columbia that allow patients access to their own lab results, and full subscription to point-of-care tools such as UpToDate by patients have flattened the information hierarchy

Medical education’s silence on death a disservice to doctors and patients

Amina Jabbar

Society is in denial about death, especially in the context of medical care. People visit their doctors for cures. Few expect to be told there is no fix, let alone that their illness will lead to their deaths. Medical education reflects that same social discourse. Though I frequently provide care to dying patients, my medical education was

Paternalism to patient-centered: do people want to know incidental findings?

Dean Regier

A recent article in Healthy Debate highlighted the possibility of uncovering incidental findings as a significant challenge in genomic sequencing. An incidental finding is a genetic condition that causes a disease unrelated to the reason genetic testing was initially ordered. For example, imagine you have been recently diagnosed with a serious disease, such as colon

Health Canada’s nutrition label changes still need improvement

Rosie Schwartz

When federal Health Minister Rona Ambrose announced proposed changes to nutrition labels this summer, dietitians and the public were excited. With the current labels, shoppers looking for healthier products needed to be either a biology expert or a math whiz to succeed. But will the new ones solve the problem? Here are five of the proposed

Lessons from Cuba on improving primary care in Canada

Chris Stone healthy debate blogger

Canada spends a significant proportion of its budget on health care, while achieving average population health outcomes compared with other OECD countries. It is difficult to achieve coordinated and comprehensive care, due in part to the strain of a dependence on acute care services, accounting for nearly 30% of total health care costs. An aging

Does collecting data take away from patient care?

As a primary care physician, I support using data for quality improvement and research. But when I recently helped a family medicine resident complete a research project, flaws in our current system became evident. Her chart review was focused on women in prenatal care who had no health insurance at my workplace, the Somerset West Community Health

Why we need to rethink the nursing home model

Verena Menec healthy debate

How many nursing home beds are needed in Canada to care for frail, elderly people with high care needs? That’s a question that policy makers across the country are grappling with, given the aging population and especially the rapidly growing number of very elderly people over the age of 85. Many people as they age

Keeping doctors where we need them

Maria Matthews Healthy Debate

How do we get more doctors to practice in rural communities?  This has been a long standing challenge in Canada — getting physicians to work where we need them — especially in provinces with large rural populations.  Policy makers have created and implemented some promising solutions, but until recently, there has been little evidence on

New technologies and more services are behind rising health costs

Michel Grignon

The tsunami metaphor is more and more often used in commentaries about the effect of aging on health care spending in Canada. It musters up images of devastation and irresistible strength submersing any levees the system might try to mount to oppose it. It is a powerful but misleading metaphor. There is a worrying rise

5 tips for writing a great health care blog

Jeremy Petch Healthy Debate Blogger

Have you thought about submitting a blog post to a website like Healthy Debate or KevinMD, but aren’t sure where to start? Have you written a few blogs and want to know how you can improve? We love receiving blog submissions (you can submit one here!) and we often get asked what makes for an

Canadian health care reform a missed opportunity

Livio Di Matteo

Expenditures on public health care in Canada appear to be slowing raising the possibility that the health care cost curve is finally being bent and the system transformed. Numbers from the Canadian Institute for Health Information show that real per capita public sector health spending peaked in 2010 at $2,687 (1997 constant dollars) and is