Healthy Debate
  • Search
  • Health topics
  • Debates
  • Special Series
  • All topics
  • All articles
Most popular today
  • COVID-19 (567)
  • Vaccines (140)
  • Opioids (52)
  • Cancer (162)
  • Addiction (172)
  • Racism (39)
  • Alcohol (23)
  • Infectious Disease (684)
  • Marijuana (22)
  • Tobacco (21)
  • Aging (213)
  • Dementia (46)
  • Long-Term Care (84)
  • Children and Youth (277)
  • Education (384)
  • Medical Education (192)
  • Depression (26)
  • Misinformation (110)
  • Nursing (29)
  • End of Life (182)
  • In Memoriam (5)
  • MAiD (33)
  • Environment (69)
  • Climate Change (35)
  • About
  • Subscribe
Opinion
Jan 30, 2012
by Ashley Miller

Is stuff making us sick? part 1

1 Comment
Share on:

As a young person just beginning my career as a physician, it is extraordinarily overwhelming to confront the disconnect between the values that created our Medicare system and the logistics of how it has evolved. Despite those incredible challenges, I am more so struck on a daily basis in practice by the manner in which our fundamental way of living perpetuates our dependency on the health care system and its emphasis on medical interventions.

Medicine pays adequate lip service to the idea of health promotion and prevention by focussing on key lifestyle interventions that can impact disease processes. Most Canadians could confidently recite that “good” eating, smoking cessation, alcohol and drug avoidance, and regular exercise might make them healthier. Discussion in medical school teaching often includes a routine allusion to the idea of the “social determinants of health,” while fundamentally failing to harness the profound therapeutic potential of radical lifestyle changes. (While I will explore this topic further in future posts, I must share Dr Terry Wahls’ TEDx Talk in which she explains her incredible recovery from end stage multiple sclerosis using food as medicine. Dr. Wahls has begun a clinical trial to test whether her own experience can be replicated in others with MS.)

While diet, exercise, and substance abuse are obvious means of impacting population health though, I have become acutely aware that some of the basic social ideals by which we live are greatly impeding our ability to be well. Though the TEDTalk mentioned above is only one in an amazing and extensive collection of work by physicians and other health care professionals related to medicine and health care, I have found myself most influenced recently by Graham Hill’s lecture entitled “Less Stuff, More Happiness.”

He very convincingly makes the case that there is a certain threshold after which additional consumption of material objects starts to mean less satisfaction. It’s also a win-win-win situation, he argues, because less stuff doesn’t only mean more happiness but also greater environmental sustainability, less debt, and better efficiency. This feels profoundly true as I examine the collection of “things” that has accumulated in my own apartment since my journey through undergraduate and medical school, and which has grown significantly through the recent addition of my partner and all of the stuff that he’s collected over the years. This inundation with material objects and our false sense of attachment to them is an enormous source of our daily stress.   In my next post, I will explore the concept of Affluenza and the evidence for links between consumerism and physical illness.

Share on:
Author

Ashley Miller

Contributor

Republish this article

Republish this article on your website under the creative commons licence.

Learn more

The comments section is closed.

1 Comment
  • Anton Hart says:
    February 2, 2012 at 11:39 am

    . .. . and better health. A few weeks ago TVO featured Neil Seeman, Timothy Caulfield, Laura Rosella, and Hank Cardello . The episode ‘Weighing it Out’ asked panelists: Is weight loss a losing game in itself? They all agreed that obesity is driven by (among many other complex drivers) the availability of food. food, food. In this case over consumption can be disastrous to health and lifestyle. It is worth watching. Just search for it on TVO.org.

Author

Ashley Miller

Contributor

Republish this article

Republish this article on your website under the creative commons licence.

Learn more

Donate to Healthy Debate

Your support allows us to publish journalism about healthcare in Canada that is free to read and free to republish. Donations are tax-deductible.

Donate

Join the mailing list

Sign up below to receive our newsletter every Thursday morning.

You can republish our articles online or in print for free. Read more.

Republish us
  • About
  • Contribute
  • Contact
  • Community Guidelines
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

Republish this article

  1. Please use the invisible republishing code below on the page where you republish this article.
  2. Please give credit to Healthy Debate and include a link back to our home page or the article URL . Our preference is a credit at the top of the article and that you include our logo  (available by clicking the link below).

Please read the full set of instructions for republication here.