Opinion

Written consent for HIV testing: Time to stop perpetuating stigma

2 Comments
  • James Owen says:

    Completely agree. It is worth further highlighting how out of date it is for health care institutions in Ontario (where I and several of the authors reside) to expect written consent for HIV testing.

    As far back as 2008, the Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care issued guidelines for HIV Counselling and Testing (https://www.catie.ca/en/resources/guidelines-hiv-counselling-and-testing) that also indicated, following CDC guidelines, that written consent was not required. More recently, the 2014 Public Health Agency of Canada HIV Screening and Testing Guide (https://www.canada.ca/en/public-health/services/hiv-aids/hiv-screening-testing-guide.html) emphasized the importance of decreasing barriers to testing. The guideline specifically states: “Clients who understand the advantages and disadvantages of HIV testing; are able to interpret the meaning of the test result; and, who understand how HIV can be transmitted are considered capable of providing verbal consent to proceed with HIV testing. Written consent is not necessary.” The guidelines also highlights the importance of positive messaging around testing including knowing one’s status and the status of one’s partners, and the benefits of early treatment.

    In light of this, I would argue that we should not just question but actively challenge institutional policies that require written consent for HIV testing in all cases, given that this practice should have been eliminated over a decade ago. These policies are out of date, are not evidence-based, and present barriers to curbing the ongoing HIV epidemic in Canada.

  • Thomas Dashwood says:

    Thank you for this much needed discussion! In my experience as a resident doctor, the process of obtaining written consent also presents a barrier to testing patients at all. In many cases, I think the process can be a deterrent, and patients go untested. This is a disservice to the patient, and concerning for public health. In other jurisdictions, HIV testing is routine. I think it should be here as well. With solid education and support from respectful and knowledgeable health teams, misinformation around HIV can be corrected, and stigma can be counteracted. HIV remains a significant problem in Ontario, and testing is an important part of reducing the spread of HIV.

Authors

Arnav Agarwal

Contributor

Arnav Agarwal is an internal medicine resident physician at the University of Toronto and an incoming fellow in general internal medicine at McMaster University. He has parallel interests in clinical epidemiology, narrative writing, medical education and health advocacy.

Jonah Himelfarb

Contributor

Jonah Himelfarb is an internal medicine resident at the University of Toronto. He is passionate about writing, health advocacy, and medical education.

Jennifer Losie

Contributor

Originally from British Columbia, Jennifer Losie is currently a third-year internal medicine resident in Calgary. She has a particular interest in infectious diseases and HIV care.

Adrienne Chan

Contributor

Adrienne Chan is an associate professor with the Division of Infectious Diseases at the University of Toronto and a physician at the Anita Rachlis Clinic at Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre.

Republish this article

Republish this article on your website under the creative commons licence.

Learn more