About Healthy Debate

Health system innovation: time to measure impact and system outcomes

Anne Snowdon healthydebate blogger health policy business

From insulin to the pacemaker, Canada has proven itself a global leader in invention.  Yet, we rank in the bottom quartile of OECD countries for innovation – a stark contrast to our record on invention.  Why?  Perhaps it is the challenge of defining innovation, and then measuring its impact so that Canadian health systems can

Why nurses are the way of the future

Why nurses are the way of the future

Our health care system is based on an on-demand model of physicians and hospitals providing acute and episodic care. While this system works well for the vast majority of citizens, it is a poor match for many of those with chronic diseases. As a nurse and an academic, my particular interest is examining how health

The most exciting part of eHealth

Rob Fraser www.healthydebate.ca blogger

When talking with my family and friends outside of healthcare I get mixed reactions to what eHealth means. Responses can range from simple to sad. “Is that like MRIs and stuff? “Do we have electronic records like at the store?” “My doctor has a Blackberry…. but I can’t email him, so I don’t know.”  However,

We should aggressively screen for cancers early… right?

Michael Wosnick healthydebate.ca blogger

How can the idea of early detection and screening for cancers even be a debate? What could possibly be the downside of catching cancers early, and treating them before they cause great harm, even death? Logic says if you can’t prevent a cancer in the first place, then diagnose it as early as you can,

Hey Doc, do you know how much that test costs?

Jeremy Petch Healthy Debate Blogger

For our health care system to remain sustainable, scarce resources must be managed effectively both at the system level and on the front lines.  In health care, decisions by doctors have a major impact on resource management in front-line care.  But our health care system does not provide doctors with all of the information they

What is “necessary” in health care?

Necessary care?

Kishore VisvanathanIt must be a tough time to be an American astronaut. Since the US Space Shuttle program shut down a year ago, their opportunities for spaceflight are limited to hitching a ride with the Russians.  It must be incredibly frustrating.  Consider the years of training, childhood dreams, and self-sacrifice – all for naught.  That

The false dichotomy of fee cuts

Kathy Hardill healthydebate blogger

Recently I had a discussion with some physician colleagues about the Ontario Medical Association (OMA) campaign and specifically the principle of communicating non-neutral, political information to our patients. The campaign to which I am referring is that seeking to solicit the support of Ontario patients for physicians who are trying to get the government back

Inter professional education 2.0: training chronic disease management professionals online

Interprofessional Chronic Disease Management

The economic costs associated with chronic diseases are significant, particularly in an era of reduced public funding and greater government accountability.  I would argue that inter-professional education (IPE) is going to emerge as a key component in the successful management and prevention of chronic diseases.  Yet true inter-professional education requires a radical rethinking of the

Patients lose in showdown between doctors and ministry

The current negotiation process between the Ministry of Health (MOH) and the Ontario Medical Association (OMA) is deeply flawed. Currently, the negotiations focus primarily on physician pay and not on the best interests of the patients. The broader issue lies not in the details of which physician services received fee cuts and by how much,

Why we need to change the revenue model for health care

Mark Macleod healthydebate blogger

There are three options when a service or product costs more or is perceived to cost more than it should – agree to pay more, find a similar product for lesser cost, or refuse to purchase.  All of these options are valid in health care, including the last one – with funders deciding that some

Publishing ER wait times – for good or evil?

Mental Health Addictions Stigma

Taking a drive through some states south of the border, you might notice a peculiar phenomenon: not only are there billboards showcasing the latest fashion or promoting certain consumer goods, but obscenely large billboards advertising the ER wait times of various hospitals. “Come to our ER! The wait is only 3 minutes to see a

Unchartered waters: bad faith bargaining or responsible government?

Steven Barret Healthy Debate Blogger

On June 12, 2012, the OMA announced its intention to launch a constitutional challenge to the Ontario Government’s decision to reduce physician fees for 37 procedures and services. No doubt the OMA’s decision to attempt to shift the locus of its dispute with the government from the bargaining table to the courts was motivated by

Pap smears: paranoia or peace of mind?

The thought of the annual Pap smear causes me as much discomfort as it does any young woman. When I read the new guidelines for cervical cancer screening in Ontario, reported in last month’s issue of Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology of Canada, I was slightly relieved at the recommendations being put forth. Rather than

Disease prevention: how much progress have we made?

Tom Closson Healthydebate blogger Prevention

A recent Canadian Institute for Health Information (CIHI) Report obscurely titled Health Indicators 2012 revisits the topic of the impact of prevention on reduced mortality which was first profiled in the 1974 Lalonde Report – A New Perspective on the Health of Canadians. This caused me to go back and reread the 38 year old

Standoff with Ontario’s docs may hold back broader health reforms

Changes to the fee structure of Ontario’s Docs are stoking a fiery dispute between the Ontario government and physicians. But the current standoff takes the momentum out of physician-centred reforms with durable opportunities for cost savings in the health sector – such as having doctors commission care on behalf of their patients. Getting better value

A sobering lesson about prevention

Zayna Khayat Healthydebate blogger prevention

By all accounts, Kaiser Permanente (a non-profit healthcare insurer and provider in the United States) is one of the best performing health care systems in the world.  Shouldn’t it follow then, that its health plan members fare better as a population in terms of their health status?  Not quite. A few weeks ago, Kaiser Permanente

Debt and health care

Health Care Costs Austerity Debt

The fiscal health of the province should not be cured by detrimental changes to the health of Ontarians. The rhetoric of rising health care costs and a population aging ‘crisis’ are a means by government, health service providers, and even the consumer to obscure reality.  The main crisis facing Ontario is a debt crisis. The

It is time to support the pharmaceutical industry

Doug Coyle Pharmaceutical Industry Drug Costs

When I present my research, a question I often get asked is “When will Canada support the pharmaceutical industry?”  What do they mean? With sales of $41.3 billion in 2009 and net revenues of $1.3 billion, the industry would in all accounts appear healthy. Furthermore, employment in the pharmaceutical industry has increased by 12% in

Healthcare cuts: lessons from pharmacy

John Greiss Healthy Debate blogger

If I harm a pt by making poor surgical decision for which evid was available to guide me;there is recourse. How is gov’t different? #onpoli — Dr. Shady Ashamalla (@AshamallaMD) June 1, 2012 Evidence-based policy. For those of us in the healthcare field, it resonates as an ideal. What better way to allocate resources than